Thursday, November 19, 2026
 
search-icon
search-icon
close-icon

Election of five judges to ICJ raises questions of judicial independence and future Kuwaiti and Gulf representation

publish time

15/11/2026

publish time

15/11/2026

Add as Preferred Source on Google

Former Executive Council Observer at the Permanent Court of Arbitration Peace Palace – The Hague
By Tareq Yousef Alshumaimry

Amid escalating international conflicts and a growing need to resort to international law, the United Nations elected five judges to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on 3 November 2026. They will serve nine-year terms beginning on 6 February 2027. The newly elected judges are Dapo Akande of the United Kingdom, François Alabrune of France, Mahmoud Daifallah Hmoud of Jordan, Rena Lee of Singapore, and Phoebe Okowa of Kenya. The Jordanian and Kenyan judges were re-elected for new full terms.
Drawing on my legal and professional experience at the Peace Palace in The Hague between 2012 and 2020, where both the International Court of Justice and the Permanent Court of Arbitration are based, and on my representation of Kuwait and the Asian continent within international justice institutions, the significance of these elections extends beyond the successful candidates.

It also concerns judicial independence, the qualifications required for membership of the Court, and the prospects for future Kuwaiti and Gulf participation in international adjudication. Elections Conducted Over Three Rounds Without the Right of Veto Nine candidates competed for five seats in elections conducted independently by the United Nations General Assembly and Security Council. Four seats were filled in the first round, while the election of Kenyan judge Phoebe Okowa required three rounds of voting.

To be elected, each candidate needed 97 votes in the General Assembly and eight votes in the Security Council, without any special voting privilege or veto power for the five permanent members. Article 10 of the ICJ Statute expressly provides that no distinction shall be made between permanent and nonpermanent members of the Security Council when electing judges. Consequently, no individual permanent member can veto a candidate who secures the required majority.
This differs from the appointment of the United Nations Secretary- General. Under Article 97 of the UN Charter, the Secretary-General is appointed by the General Assembly upon the recommendation of the Security Council. Such a recommendation is a substantive decision governed by Article 27 and may therefore be blocked by a permanent member’s veto. This distinction reflects the different legal frameworks governing the two processes. Judicial elections are subject to a specific safeguard against privileged voting by major powers, whereas the Security Council retains a decisive role in recommending the appointment of the UN’s chief administrative officer.
The veto does not automatically extend to other international appointments. For example, judges and the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court are elected under the Rome Statute without a Security Council vote. By contrast, substantive Security Council decisions establishing international institutions or missions and determining their mandates may be subject to the veto, although this does not mean that every appointment within such institutions requires Security Council approval. The International Court of Justice: Fifteen Judges Independent of Governments
Established in 1945 and operational since 1946, the International Court of Justice is headquartered at the Peace Palace in The Hague. It comprises fifteen judges elected for nine-year terms, with five seats renewed every three years. The Court adjudicates legal disputes between states when a valid basis for jurisdiction exists. It also delivers advisory opinions at the request of duly authorized international bodies. It is distinct from the International Criminal Court, which exercises criminal jurisdiction over individuals accused of crimes falling within its mandate. The ICJ applies international treaties, customary international law, and general principles of law, while also drawing upon judicial decisions and legal scholarship in accordance with its Statute. Judges do not represent their national governments, and no two judges may hold the nationality of the same state. The Court’s composition must also reflect the principal legal systems and main forms of civilization worldwide.

The Newly Elected Judges: Academic Qualifications and International Experience Dapo Akande – United Kingdom Akande holds a Bachelor of Laws degree from the University of Ife in Nigeria and a Master of Laws from the London School of Economics and Political Science. He is Professor of Public International Law at the University of Oxford and a member of the United Nations International Law Commission. His areas of expertise include armed conflict, international immunities, and the use of force. François Alabrune – France Alabrune studied law at the University of Limoges and graduated from Sciences Po Paris and France’s École nationale d’administration. He served as Director of Legal Affairs at the French Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs and as France’s Ambassador to the Netherlands. He also participated in negotiations leading to the establishment of the International Criminal Court. Mahmoud Daifallah Hmoud – Jordan Hmoud holds a Bachelor of Laws from the University of Jordan, a Master of Laws from George Washington University, a diploma in international human rights law from the Raoul Wallenberg Institute at Lund University, and a further Master of Laws from Franklin Pierce Law Center.
He served as Jordan’s Permanent Representative to the United Nations and chaired the International Law Commission in 2021. Rena Lee – Singapore Lee holds both a Bachelor of Laws and a Master of Laws from the National University of Singapore, as well as an honorary doctorate in law from the University of Aberdeen. She served as Singapore’s Ambassador for International Law and chaired the negotiations that led to the adoption of the 2023 Agreement on Marine Biological Diversity of Areas beyond National Jurisdiction. Her expertise includes the law of the sea. Phoebe Okowa – Kenya Okowa holds a Bachelor of Laws from the University of Nairobi, a professional legal qualification from the Kenya School of Law, and postgraduate legal qualifications, including a doctorate, from the University of Oxford. She is Professor of Public International Law at Queen Mary University of London and specializes in state responsibility and international environmental law. These professional backgrounds reveal three principal pathways to international judicial office: academic research and scholarship; legal diplomacy and government advisory work; and legal practice, advocacy, and international arbitration.

These pathways frequently overlap. Neither prior service as a national judge nor possession of a doctoral degree is necessarily required, provided that candidates satisfy the standards of professional competence, integrity, and independence established by the Court’s Statute.

Five Major Cases Highlighting the Court’s Judicial Responsibilities
The elections coincide with significant cases before the International Court of Justice involving matters of global and regional concern, particularly for the Arab world. South Africa v. Israel
The case concerns the application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in the Gaza Strip. The Court issued provisional measures during 2024, which did not constitute a final determination that genocide had occurred. Palestine v. United States of America
This case concerns the relocation of the United States Embassy to Jerusalem and raises legal questions relating to the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations and the Court’s jurisdiction. Canada and the Netherlands v. Syria
The proceedings concern obligations under the Convention against Torture, including state responsibility for preventing alleged violations and investigating acts of torture. Iran v. United States of America
The dispute concerns alleged violations of the 1955 Treaty of Amity, Economic Relations, and Consular Rights, highlighting the relevance of international adjudication to disputes affecting the Gulf region. Ukraine v. Russia
This case concerns the interpretation and application of the Genocide Convention in the context of the Russia– Ukraine war and raises questions about the limits of the Court’s jurisdiction. Together, these cases illustrate the distinction between delivering a binding judicial decision and ensuring its implementation. Article 94 of the United Nations Charter requires parties to comply with ICJ judgments in cases to which they are parties. Where a state fails to comply, the other party may bring the matter before the Security Council, where political considerations and the veto may again become relevant to substantive decisions.

Kuwait and the Gulf: When Will a Judge from the Region Reach the Peace Palace?
These elections raise a question deserving serious consideration by Kuwaiti and Gulf legal and diplomatic institutions: Why should Kuwait or another Gulf Cooperation Council state not begin preparing a qualified candidate for election to the International Court of Justice, following the examples of Jordan and Singapore, as well as earlier Arab representation from Morocco, Algeria, and Egypt? Kuwait’s modern history is closely linked to the principles of international legitimacy, particularly following the Iraqi invasion of 1990.
The country has valuable experience in defending state sovereignty and supporting the peaceful settlement of international disputes through legal mechanisms. Gulf Cooperation Council states also possess accumulated expertise in diplomacy, arbitration, maritime law, and international relations.
There are no seats specifically reserved for Kuwait or the Gulf. Nominations are submitted through national groups associated with the Permanent Court of Arbitration, or equivalent national groups established under the ICJ Statute, while election requires the necessary majorities in both the General Assembly and the Security Council.
The experiences of Jordan and Singapore demonstrate that access to the Court does not depend primarily on a state’s size, but rather on developing internationally recognized legal expertise. This calls for a long-term Gulf strategy combining advanced academic training, participation in the work of the International Law Commission, practical experience in international judicial and arbitral institutions, and diplomatic support for qualified candidates, while fully respecting their judicial independence. The next regular elections are scheduled for 2029, for terms beginning in February 2030. Special elections may also take place if a seat becomes vacant before the expiry of its term.

From the Peace Palace to the Future of International Justice
The 2026 elections demonstrate that judicial independence depends not only on legal provisions, but also on the qualifications, integrity, and professional judgment of judges who must apply international law independently of governmental interests. They also underline the importance of strengthening Arab and Gulf legal participation in international institutions as a means of promoting the rule of law. Given The Hague’s central position in international justice, preparing a qualified Kuwaiti or Gulf candidate for election to the International Court of Justice should be regarded as a serious institutional objective requiring early planning and sustained professional development. A nation’s international standing is measured not only by its political and economic presence, but also by the legal expertise it contributes independently to the advancement of international justice.